Firehouse Subs does not have an official secret menu, but many locations allow fan-favorite hacks and old menu items. Popular choices include the Brisket Hat Trick with brisket, turkey, and ham, or the BBQ Bacon Cheddar Meatball with extra smoky toppings.
These items are not shown on the menu, so you may need to tell the staff the exact ingredients. You can also order older items like the Engine Company by asking for the original meat combo. This lets you customize your sub and enjoy something different from the regular menu.
Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket
Small: $8.89 — 450 Calories
Medium: $11.19 — 890 Calories
Large: $15.99 — 1500 Calories
Sweet & Spicy Meatball
Small: $5.49 — 470 Calories
Medium: $9.49 — 940 Calories
Large: $13.99 — 1450 Calories
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Small: $6.99 – $8.49
Medium: $10.49 – $12.99
Large: $14.99 – $17.49
The New Yorker
Small: $6.99 – $8.49
Medium: $10.49 – $12.49
Large: $14.99 – $17.99
Italian
Small: $5.49 — 470 Calories
Medium: $9.49 — 940 Calories
Large: $13.99 — 1450 Calories
Firehouse Hero
Small: $7.39 — 400 Calories
Medium: $10.29 — 790 Calories
Large: $14.49 — 1180 Calories
Buffalo Chicken
Small: $6.29 – $7.49
Medium: $8.99 – $10.99
Large: $13.49 – $15.99
Italian
Small: $5.49 — 470 Calories
Medium: $9.49 — 940 Calories
Large: $13.99 — 1450 Calories
Ultimate Steak and Cheese
Small: $7.39 — 400 Calories
Medium: $10.29 — 790 Calories
Large: $14.49 — 1180 Calories
The California
Small: $7.49 – $8.99
Medium: $10.99 – $12.49
Large: $15.49 – $18.49
French Dip
Small: $5.49 — 470 Calories
Medium: $9.49 — 940 Calories
Large: $13.99 — 1450 Calories
FAQs
What is the Firehouse Subs secret menu?
The secret menu includes hidden custom subs like Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket and Chicken Bacon Ranch, made from standard ingredients but not listed officially.
How do you order secret menu items at Firehouse Subs?
Politely ask staff by name (e.g., “Sweet & Spicy Meatball”) or describe the build; they’re open to customizations during less busy times.
Is Smokehouse Beef & Cheddar Brisket on the secret menu?
Yes, it features smoked brisket, melted cheddar, and BBQ sauce on a sub roll, a fan-favorite hidden item.
What’s the Sweet & Spicy Meatball secret sub?
Meatballs smothered in Firehouse’s sweet and spicy sauce, served on a roll for $6.39-$11.49 depending on size.
Are secret menu items available everywhere?
No, availability varies by location due to ingredient stock; confirm with your local Firehouse Subs.
What is the Chicken Bacon Ranch secret sub?
Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, and creamy ranch dressing combined for a savory, textured sandwich at $6.69-$11.99.
Can you get Buffalo Chicken off-menu?
Yes, roasted chicken in buffalo sauce with lettuce, tomato, and ranch side, priced $6.99-$11.99.
What’s the Ultimate Steak & Cheese secret item?
Thinly sliced steak with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and onion—a beefier take on the classic for $6.99-$12.49.
Is The New Yorker on the secret menu?
Yes, it combines premium meats like pastrami and corned beef with mustard and Swiss, customizable per location.
Are prices different for secret menu subs?
No, they use standard pricing by size and ingredients, typically $6-$13; expect variations by location and promotions.